How Hidden Assumptions Shape Workplace Dynamics — and How We Can Shift Them

As a corporate trainer and social worker, I’ve seen how the most well-intentioned workplaces can still struggle with inclusion—not because of overt discrimination, but because of something more subtle: hidden assumptions. These are the unspoken beliefs and mental shortcuts we all carry, shaped by our experiences, culture, and environment. While they’re a natural part of how we navigate the world, they can quietly influence how we interact, make decisions, and perceive others at work.

The encouraging news? Once we recognize these patterns, we can shift them—and create more inclusive, innovative, and connected workplaces.

What Are Hidden Assumptions?

Hidden assumptions are the automatic judgments or expectations we form about people or situations without conscious awareness. They help us process information quickly, but they can also lead us to overlook talent, misinterpret behavior, or unintentionally exclude others.

These assumptions might relate to someone’s background, communication style, appearance, or even job title. And because they often go unexamined, they can shape workplace dynamics in ways we don’t always realize.

Where They Show Up

Hidden assumptions can influence:

• Hiring and promotions: Favoring candidates who “seem like a good fit” based on familiarity rather than qualifications.
• Team interactions: Giving more space to certain voices while unintentionally sidelining others.
• Feedback and evaluations: Offering different types of feedback based on assumptions about personality or potential.
• Everyday decisions: Making snap judgments about someone’s capabilities or intentions.

These patterns can limit opportunities, reduce engagement, and create barriers to belonging. But they’re not fixed—they can be shifted with awareness and intention.

Strategies to Shift Hidden Assumptions

Here are some practical, strengths-based strategies I share in training sessions to help teams recognize and shift hidden assumptions:

1. Pause and Reflect

Encourage a culture of reflection. Before making decisions or forming impressions, take a moment to ask: “What assumptions might I be making here?”

2. Create Space for All Voices

Use inclusive meeting practices—like rotating facilitators, inviting input from quieter team members, and acknowledging contributions—to ensure everyone feels heard.

3. Standardize Key Processes

In hiring, promotions, and performance reviews, use structured criteria and diverse panels to reduce the influence of subjective impressions.

4. Foster Ongoing Learning

Offer regular learning opportunities that explore topics like inclusive leadership, cultural humility, and emotional intelligence. Learning should be continuous, not one-and-done.

5. Lead with Curiosity

Replace judgment with curiosity. When we approach differences with a mindset of learning rather than labeling, we open the door to deeper understanding and connection.

A More Inclusive Workplace Starts with Awareness

Hidden assumptions don’t make us bad—they make us human. But when we bring them into the light, we gain the power to choose differently. As someone who bridges the worlds of organizational development and social impact, I believe that workplaces can be both high-performing and deeply human. By recognizing and shifting our hidden assumptions, we create space for everyone to thrive.

Written by: Erin McKown, LMSW, Director of Corporate Development & Training at National EAP

‍